Lots of parenting interventions are now considered evidence-based, including several that are attachment-based (ABC, Circle of Security, Child-Parent Psychotherapy and Promote Positive Parenting (per Berlin et al 2016 chapter 32 "Prevention and Early Intervention Programs to Support Early Attachment Security.")). I keep asking myself "what is wrong with these programs? Why do I hate some of them so much?" The answer is coming to me and it's about measurement. What are we measuring and why? So many of the parenting studies I have seen (not necessarily pertaining to the aforementioned interventions) look at the impact of the intervention on the child's behavior. While this is certainly relevant - and we know that the parent's behavior and ability to self-regulate impacts the child's behavior - it is tricky to consider this one factor in what is really a dyadic relationship. Furthermore, very often the parents complain about child behavior that is completely developmentally normal! Are these parenting programs addressing developmental norms? How are we measuring extreme behavior in children?
Additionally - and I think this is a really important piece that is often neglected - are we measuring the level of parent and child satisfaction with the parenting/parent-child relationship? This matters! It's really, really important to know how children feel about their relationships to their parents, including whether or not they think their parents treat them fairly, kindly, respectfully and lovingly.
Now, there are certainly many situations in which children who are NOT being treated with respect by the adults in their lives that they will still tell you that they know their parent loves them, that they love their parent, etc. And children do not have an objective way to know whether the way they are being treated is "normal," "appropriate" or even fair. They get treated the way they get treated and that's the norm in their home.
Research idea: what if we asked children what they thought about the parenting relationship? What questions might we ask? How young of a child could we ask these questions of?
Of course, we cannot ask these questions of 0-3 year olds, and this is a critical time period. But maybe we could continue to do the interventions and conduct follow-up interviews with children at various time periods (age 5, age 8, age 12...?) I am really curious to know if children who are parented in an attachment-focused way have better outcomes - including a better experience of being parented - than kids who are parented in more traditional ways. I am also interested in the parent's own satisfaction with their parenting relationship when they parent in an attachment-focused way. Do they enjoy parenting more? Do they have a more satisfying relationship with their partner as a result of more harmonious family life? Is family life more harmonious when adults parent in this way?
Getting back to "what's wrong with parenting interventions"...are the interventions addressing childhood trauma? I mean, really addressing it. Circle of Security does a beautiful job with the introduction of "shark music" as a way of understanding how trauma and other negative aspects of their own childhood may be impacting their parenting. This is beautiful. Are the interventions addressing parent self-regulation and self-care? Are they doing it well?
Are parenting interventions teaching about the brain - both child and parent brain - as part of the developmental norms piece of the curriculum? Is this information helpful to parents?
Is a "new paradigm" of thinking about children being introduced as part of the implication of this new information?
Are studies being done on low-risk families? Are low-risk families signing up for this kind of parenting class? Do we still call it an intervention if it's just a low-risk family seeking more information/a better way of doing things?
**Article: Parenting from the Outside-In by Joe Coyne (Australia) talks about the paradigm shift, Dan Siegel and what's wrong with Triple P. "...reflects
the idea that PT represents a mode of parenting that seeks to
influence child outcomes by altering external contingencies via
the parent." YES. Exactly. The outcome is NOT improvement of child behavior. It's quality of relationship!!
No comments:
Post a Comment